Categories

An Interview with David Tubb

For those not familiar with him, David Tubb is a truly exceptional marksman, with a wall of trophies too long to list – suffice to say that it begins with 11 NRA High Power trophies form Camp Perry. He has written two books on precision shooting, and sells a long range target rifle of his own design. We had the privilege of speaking with him recently, and discussed the new line of ammunition he will be bringing to market shortly. If there is anyone who understands the elements that go into extremely accurate ammunition, it’s David Tubb.

CNC Machines are not Magic

Today we’re taking a look at what is required to use a modern CNC machining center to reproduce a part designed for factory production on a bank of horizontal milling machines. It’s not as trivial as many people think –  CNC has some definite limitations. The part is from an RP46 top cover, a conversion to made the DP28/DPM light machine gun into a belt-fed weapon instead of using pan magazines.

What Not to Do: Vulcan V15

We just got this Vulcan V15 AR15/AR18 hybrid in, and boy should you see it. Good idea; horrible execution.

We’ll do another video in a little while looking at the AR-18, the Leader T2, and this Vulcan POS to discuss how we can get the best out of the lot of ‘em.

A Slightly Different Take on Pakistani Gunmaking

We’ve all heard about the guys making knockoff firearms in Pakistan with vices and hand files. Well, Al-Jazeera English did a story on some of these guys, with a somewhat different focus than you usually see. Apparently, they are really concerned about government crackdowns on armsmakers (where have we heard that refrain before?), and in particular that a general transition to computer-controlled tools will put them out of business.

(hat tip to Every Day No Days Off for the video)

One the one hand, my initial reaction is that a move to CNC equipment (even if it’s being used with C-clamps) is probably a big step up for the average Pakistani firearms buyer. On the other hand, you don’t get to stay in a job for 40 years if you make a lot of guns that blow up. Some of these guys are probably amazingly talented at what they do, and it’s a shame to see those skills lost. Of course, the economically sensible course if you are that guy is to cater to a high-end market and promote your hand-made custom quality instead of making generic knockoffs like everyone else.

Also, maybe a test stand for the proof firing would be a reasonable idea.

My First Part: G41(W) Gas Piston

I’ve been working on the lathe for a couple days at school, and been doing turning and drilling (no threading yet). I finished the sample piece my instructor wanted (a cylinder with several different diameters and grooves, which we will be using for threading instruction tomorrow), and I was looking for something to practice these operations on today. After flipping through some old copies of Home Shop Machinist, I realized that the perfect item to make would be a gas piston from the Walther G41(W) that I was looking at last week over at Forgotten Weapons. It’s a very simple piece, which slides over the barrel and inside a thin cover. It is pushed by gas briefly trapped by the muzzle cone of the rifle, and acts on a connecting rod to move the bolt. The upshot is that it’s a simple cylinder with three gas seal grooves cut on the outside surface and two more on the inside surface.

Walther G41(W) piston

Walther G41(W) piston (original on the left, mine on the right, piston cover piece below)

So, I broke out the gas piston from our G41(W), and began by doing a basic reverse engineering of it. I drew out the part and used  series of tools to measure all the important dimensions. A basic dial micrometer for the outside measurements, a micrometer with pointed contacts for the groove diameters, and a digital caliper for the inside diameter (I don’t have a good tool for precise measurement of inside diameters, as it’s larger than the set of plug gauges we have).

Once the part was drawn out, I pulled a piece of 1″ diameter stainless stock from the steel room (the original is made of stainless, since it is exposed to hot, high pressure gasses on every shot), and chucked it up in the lathe. I first faced it off, and then turned down the OD with a series of cuts until I had the proper 0.904″ diameter. Next I used a cutoff tool to cut the exterior grooves, followed by a series of drilling operations to cut the ID. We don’t have a reamer of the specific 0.650″ diameter necessary for this part, so I instead used a boring tool to cut the final inside diameter. Not nearly as fine a finish as a reamer, but it will work. A second boring cutter allowed me to cut the interior gas relief grooves, and then back to the cutoff tool to, well, cut off the part from the stock.

This took me about 4 hours from start to finish, and it does have several problems. My speeds and feed rates on the first two grooves were not ideal (and I was using an HSS cutting tool on a stainless part, which is not recommended), and that led to a lot of chatter. The inside diameter should be reamed for a smoother finish, and the inside gas relief grooves are not deep enough (we would be best served to make a specific tool for that operation if we were to make a bunch of these parts).

Once I had the final piece in hand, I did a little buffing to the outside to clean up some burred edges, and tested it out on the rifle. It actually fits! :) My first actual gun part, and it fits both over the rifle barrel and inside the cover with the same feel as the original part.

I expect we will be revisiting this piece down the road when I start running the CNC lathe – it could be done in a single program on the CNC, and will be a good practice job.